Fruit before bed: an older couple share a bowl of kiwis and mandarins on the sofa while their granddaughter reads a story aloud
|

Fruit before bed or as dessert: what is true about the myths?

General information, not medical advice. If you have symptoms or follow a diet for medical reasons, discuss it with your GP or dietitian.

Fruit before bed or as dessert: according to some social media posts, it is bad for digestion or sleep. Here is what actually happens in your body and what studies found about fruit and sleep.

Myth 1: fruit after a meal ferments in your stomach

The idea comes from food-combining diets, which claim that carbohydrates, proteins and fats get in each other’s way during digestion. NICE, the Belgian nutrition information centre, says this theory rests on a misunderstanding of digestion. Carbohydrates, proteins and fats are digested side by side, each by its own enzymes, the proteins that cut food into small pieces.

Fermentation is a normal part of digestion, but it happens mainly in the large intestine. Gut bacteria there break down undigested leftovers, such as fruit fibre, whether you ate the fruit with or between meals. According to NICE, fruit with a meal can even help: its vitamin C improves the absorption of iron from plant foods. The Vlaams Instituut Gezond Leven also names fruit as dessert after a hot meal or sandwiches as a good option.

Myth 2: eating fruit before bed keeps you awake

Research for this article turned up no study showing that a piece of fruit in the evening disturbs sleep. What matters is amount and timing. A large meal just before bed can disturb some people’s nights, as the article on evening meals and sleep explains. An apple or a couple of mandarins is not a large meal. If you sleep worse on a full stomach, eat a little earlier.

Kiwi and cherries for better sleep: what do studies say?

Two small studies get a lot of attention. In a 2011 Taiwanese study, 24 adults with sleep problems ate two kiwis every evening for four weeks, an hour before bed. They fell asleep faster and slept a little longer. But there was no control group, so it is unclear how much was due to the kiwi.

In a 2012 British study, 20 healthy adults drank tart cherry juice concentrate for one week and a placebo, a drink without an active ingredient, for another week, so everyone got both. With the cherry juice, researchers found more of a melatonin breakdown product in the urine, and participants slept a little longer. Melatonin is the hormone your body makes in the evening that supports your body clock, also called circadian rhythm, the internal clock of about 24 hours. This study was also small and short, and the concentrate contains far more cherries than a bowl.

The results are interesting but too thin to recommend kiwi or cherries as a sleep aid. In these two studies there was no sign that kiwi or cherries disturbed sleep. They say nothing about fruit in general.

What actually helps?

Eating fruit at whatever time suits you is fine. Pay most attention to how much and how late you eat in the evening. A short walk after eating also helps manage blood sugar. If you get reflux after fruit, citrus can sit less well in the evening: that is a personal reaction, not a reason to advise everyone against fruit. If you often have reflux, talk to your GP.

For how much fruit to eat across the day, read the article how much fruit per day.

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *